img_5673Earlier this summer, there was a sudden rush to finally, finally rid several Southern cities of the statues that littered them and which were memorials to the Confederate side of the Civil War.  The side that lost, but that held on to a grudge that still lasts.

tumblr_ox039q5l7o1qz6f9yo5_1280Most of them had been nominally erected by the widows and mothers and children of men who had marched off, but never came back.  That is, granted, a sad motivation, but just behind the respectable shield of grieving for the dead was the horrible reality of what those men had died for.  Those idiot boys had gone to war to protect the institution of slavery


Growing up as I did in Texas in the 1950s and 60s seemed to be the end times for sentimentality over the Civil War.  The passionate,Victorian era clock-winders that I had read about or seen in movies were all gone.  I went to a white elementary school, but integration had found its way into my unimportant little burg by the time I entered middle and high school.  The circle of losers and nerds who comprised my friends had black members; my parents seethed that I had black friends.  The century of the war ending happened the year I turned 9, and to a 9-year-old, a century is the definition of forever.


And then boom, this summer, we are suddenly back to Great Lost Era of mrpeenee’s Ninth Year.  I had seen the statues and memorials and ignored them.  Considering they had lost, the South had a mania for enduring no one would forget.  OK.  Won’t forget, got it on my to do list.  Only, I never once considered what we were be excoriated to remember.  I had black friends in a high school named for Robert E. Lee, the major commander of the southern forces.  I had more immediate things to ignore.


So now the statues have been removed, some by work crews who had to disguise the company’s name and their own identities because the tempest over that removal was so hot.  And now all that’s left behind are the bases, or plinths, they rested on.  There is a much lower pitch struggle over how to deal with them.


I say leave them, now as memorials to the struggle a lot of right-minded people fought over more than a century that their generals and statesmen graced them and that they were a constant source of irritation and pain to the descendents of the slaves those men fought and died to make sure remained slaves.


Even with the monuments gone, no one is going to forget the Civil War or the guilt America bears for allowing some men to own other men in the first place.  Several of the plinths are very attractive in their own right and with the statues gone, all they are is sort of sad.  Leaving them standing empty is not some defiant, sore loser gesture against the fight to remove the shameful memorials but as a salute for a long, grinding fight that was finally won.

I’m proud of the people who fought that fight and congratulate them.  Maybe they should have a salute for all they did.  Maybe they should have a monument.


15 responses »

    • exactly. Some of them were sort of obscure , but plenty of them, like the Robert E. Lee statue in New Orleans were very prominent, it’s the column in the first picture. with the base already in place and with all the cost that represents, not re-using them for a more appropriate piece of art is ludicrous.


  1. Those plinths held memorials to bigotry; they should be used for memorials for those who fought AGAINST bigotry. Statues of Dr. King, Nelson Mandela, Rosa Parks, or Desmond Tutu would be appropriate. So would statues of the Stonewall rioters, Harvey Milk, Betty Friedan, RuPaul, Barack Obama, and many, many more. Might even have to build more plinths…!


  2. Oh hai hai. Similarly I blog when the muse strikes. But I digress. I think I have a solution to the statue removal turmoil. Leave them.

    But nearby allow those families that are descendants of slaves to erect a monument that would be something like “The XXX family; slaves to the XXX family” Then a bullet point list of family descendants leading to present times, names/addresses: “Ronald and Nancy White – 1234 Street, Charleston”

    Though with the current political pulse there are probably fucks out there who would be PROUD to have their family name listed on a slave owner memorial statue.


  3. Having lived in (and still living at times) in the South, I’m always a bit surprised at having to remind people (particularly home grown Southerners) that yes, the South fought for states rights–The right to keep people as slaves!!! Dress it up all you want, but slavery is wrong.

    I have a proposal for all those empty podiums/pedestals. Instead of arguing over who should be on there, I agree that it should be some sort of art. I think that instead of people, how about critters and food that are iconic and symbolize the region? Like crawfish holding up a pot of gumbo for New Orleans? Or a BBQ chicken drenched in white sauce for Alabama? A catfish holding up a mud pie for Mississippi? A manatee with a key lime pie for Florida? It’d be good for tourism!


    • “a BBQ chicken drenched in white sauce …” What? Is that a real thing? I think I’m going to have nightmares.

      But I like your idea about celebrating deliciousness. Except maybe in Alabama.


      • I do not know much about Alabama, except what I hear here in Europe about this Roy Moore chap. So I think on a plinth in Alabama should be a tit, a gun and a bleeding bible. Cover it in White Sauce to make it clear for the silliest.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s